José Bosch, President of the CAEB Menorca Restaurant Association: “After the bubble, we’ve returned to reality”

José Bosch, President of the CAEB Menorca Restaurant Association: “After the bubble, we’ve returned to reality”

Itziar Lecea / Ciutadella – With a 2025 season that has begun rather unevenly, José Bosch reflects on the possible causes behind the drop in revenue in Menorca’s restaurant sector. He also points to the consequences that certain anti-tourism attitudes may have on local hospitality businesses.

Would you say that the 2025 season is a bad one?
We could say that we’re back to reality. After COVID, 2022 was indescribable; in 2023, we still carried the post-lockdown euphoria; and last year, we began to see warning signs, but the bubble effect was fading. Now, in 2025, we’re facing a truly normal tourist season in Menorca, with an increase in tour operator-driven demand. There are new high-end accommodation options, but they are a minority. Unlike Ibiza, where such establishments have a strong impact, that’s not the case here. Visitors come seeking peace and quiet — which, for restaurants, translates into low spending levels.

Is the end of the bubble the only cause of this decline?
No, we’re also hurt by high airfare prices and a large accommodation offer within a context of inflation, high costs, and economic instability. As a result, when tourists arrive in Menorca, they have little left to spend. The destination takes priority over services, meaning visitors spend less. That’s been clear in the first half of the season.

This is noticeable in town businesses. What about in resort areas?
In the resorts, there’s more package tourism. Even so, the drop in average spend is visible everywhere — both in towns and in tourist zones. It’s ironic, because the numbers seem to contradict us: airport arrivals remain high, but people are moving less, walking less, and spending less. We also need to recognize that all these anti-tourism campaigns are harmful and will eventually backfire. Everyone has the right to express their opinion, of course, but it’s been done without much thought about real consequences.

How can these campaigns have an impact?
We always say the season needs to be extended at the beginning and end. This year, the start was already difficult, and we’ve seen the first consequences of what I’ve just described. The weather hasn’t helped either, leading to last-minute bookings. Moreover, restaurants are becoming an increasingly inaccessible sector.

Because of rising prices? Or are there other reasons?
Prices are going up because we have no choice. Inflation is out of control — just ask any purchasing manager, and they’ll tell you prices rise every other week. The new hospitality agreement also contributes to higher final prices, since wages must be maintained.

The latest version of that agreement was approved this July. How is it affecting businesses?
The Balearic hospitality agreement — and I’m not saying workers shouldn’t be well paid, because otherwise we won’t find good professionals — estimates that each employee costs around €15,000 in monthly turnover. It’s a deal written with the Mallorcan hotel industry in mind, negotiated between the Mallorcan Hotel Federation and a trade union. But it doesn’t reflect Menorca’s restaurant reality, or even that of small hoteliers. A restaurant in Ciutadella doesn’t generate the same turnover as a hotel chain in Mallorca. This complaint is long-standing: a worker in a resort open ten months a year shouldn’t be under the same agreement as a waiter in a small Menorcan restaurant that operates six months.

According to the National Statistics Institute, the average hospitality cost per employee is €2,500 in Spain, compared to €3,700 in the Balearic Islands. That means a restaurant considering hiring one more worker must allocate 30–35% of total revenue to staff, 30% to purchases, 20% to expenses, and the rest to profit. To make the math work, each employee needs to generate €15,000 per month.

And there’s still a shortage of workers!
There are several factors. Working hours are one. Years ago, you could earn more by working overtime, but now, by law, you can’t exceed 40 hours a week. Decades ago, seasonal workers came from the mainland — they could earn enough in six months to live all year — but now, with housing shortages, that’s no longer viable. Today, it’s much harder to make good money in hospitality: overtime is gone, and so are things like the “sixth day,” which allowed one extra, well-paid workday.

What are the consequences of these costs?
We’re killing off popular gastronomy. There are no more €12–13 set menus. Families feel it: before, they went out to eat a couple of times a week; now, maybe once or not at all.

Are businesses cutting staff?
I haven’t heard of layoffs, but some are giving staff holidays in the middle of the season. There are also places that hired more people than necessary based on overly optimistic forecasts.

Will 2025 help balance the labour market?
Hard to say. The world is changing fast, and the service sector feels it immediately. This is a battle we fight every season. Some businesses overhired this year; next year they may underhire and struggle. It’s unpredictable. What’s clear is that we need to stay grounded: the last three years were anything but normal, due to post-pandemic effects.

Could other destinations hurt Menorca in the medium term?
Yes. There are already international destinations that are cheaper for Spanish tourists than coming to Menorca. That’s one reason many are choosing to go abroad. I recently read that a week in Menorca costs an average of €2,700, while a trip to Cancún is cheaper. Tourism is never stable; we must stay vigilant. Building a destination brand takes years, but losing trust is easy. Tourism must be promoted — it’s a business, after all.

  • Publicitat
    Ràdio Far Menorca
  • Publicitat
    El Iris